Tribal by Michael Morris How the Cultural Instincts That Divide Us Can Help Bring Us Together

What's it about?
Tribal (2024) explores the deep-rooted cultural instincts that drive human behavior, revealing how our need for belonging, admiration, and tradition shapes our decisions. By recognizing these instincts, we can leverage them to foster positive change, build stronger communities, and create more meaningful connections.


What drives people to form tight-knit groups, rally around shared beliefs, and fiercely defend their traditions? Whether it’s a die-hard sports fanbase, a loyal corporate team, or a centuries-old cultural identity, human beings are wired to seek belonging. Our desires for connection, admiration, and tradition shape our decisions and behaviors – sometimes in surprising ways.

For example, take South Korea’s preparation for the 2002 World Cup. Aside from merely improving their team’s performance on the field – they required a fundamental shift in mindset. The team’s longstanding cultural traditions emphasized deference to authority and rigid hierarchy, which ended up limiting opportunities for younger players and made the team’s approach on the field utterly predictable. But when Guus Hiddink, a seasoned Dutch coach, took the reins, his unorthodox strategies pushed the team outside its comfort zone. Hiddink introduced sweeping changes to player selection and training methods. While controversial at first, his approach began to reveal untapped potential within the squad – reflecting a broader ability to adapt and reimagine entrenched traditions. Hiddink’s methods displayed how cultural patterns, often viewed as immovable, can be altered when circumstances demand it. By challenging the old ways, the team developed a fresh sense of unity and flexibility that prepared them to compete at the highest level.

By exploring the patterns behind group identity, you’ll discover how shared stories, rituals, and instincts influence everything from politics to business. Why do we instinctively trust those within our group while remaining skeptical of outsiders? How do traditions strengthen our sense of belonging? And most importantly, how can we use this knowledge to create stronger, more inclusive communities?

In this lesson, we’ll walk you through key insights into human nature, showing how to navigate and leverage cultural instincts for leadership, influence, and collaboration. Whether you’re interested in understanding social dynamics, improving team cohesion, or simply making sense of human behavior, you’re about to embark on a fascinating journey into what truly binds us together.
Let’s start with some basics. Humans haven’t survived by being the strongest or fastest – they’ve thrived because of their ability to cooperate. Early humans, like Homo erectus, discovered that working together made life possible in ways individual effort never could. For instance, persistence hunting, where a group chased prey to the point of exhaustion, required planning, endurance, and teamwork. Beyond hunting, cooperation extended to foraging, which required sharing knowledge of food sources and collaborative effort. Collecting diverse resources like nuts, tubers, and water lilies was often a group activity, benefitting from the combined skills and efficiency of working together. Cooking meals further reinforced these cooperative behaviors, as shared meals became central to group bonding.

This teamwork was supported by the development of the peer instinct, which allowed humans to learn from one another in ways other primates couldn’t. Unlike chimpanzees, who lack the ability to plan long-term tasks, divide labor, or develop shared knowledge, humans created a culture of observation, imitation, and innovation. Skills like tool use, fire management, and collective problem-solving flourished, fostering a level of cooperation unmatched by any other species.

As humans started forming tighter social bonds, rituals and symbols emerged as tools to strengthen their connections. These were far from arbitrary acts; they had both practical and symbolic purposes. Rituals, such as communal gatherings, often organized labor for large projects like temple-building or collective hunts, while symbols reinforced shared identity and trust within the group. By participating in these practices, individuals solidified their belonging and their shared purpose. This combination of practical function and symbolic meaning made rituals integral to group cohesion.

Tribal instincts – cooperation, peer learning, and rituals – weren’t mere survival tools but the foundation for interconnected, trusting groups. They enabled the advanced social structures that define humanity today.
It’s 1920. Prohibition has just gone into effect across the United States. The temperance movement, driven by decades of grassroots advocacy, has successfully pushed the Eighteenth Amendment into law, banning the sale of alcohol. Public pledge events and media campaigns flood the country, making abstinence a visible marker of moral character. Lawmakers, under intense pressure, align themselves with this growing movement, creating the appearance of overwhelming public support for the ban.

For a while, the illusion held. But cracks began to show when a magazine poll revealed a hidden “wet” majority – citizens who opposed Prohibition. Suddenly, public debate reignited. Resistance grew as Americans questioned whether the cultural signals they’d been following truly reflected the nation’s values. By 1933, the Twenty-First Amendment repealed Prohibition, unraveling the temperance movement’s once-dominant narrative. This dramatic reversal highlighted the power – and limits – of cultural signals. They can shape behavior and create societal norms, but when disconnected from shared values, they’re vulnerable to collapse.

The power of storytelling on societal behavior should also never be taken for granted. Narratives can be even more persuasive than facts because they resonate emotionally. Brazilian telenovelas in the 1970s and 1980s are a clear example. They portrayed modern, independent women and smaller families, challenging traditional norms. As these shows reached new regions, birth rates dropped, and women embraced the lives modeled by the characters – even naming their children after them. Intentional storytelling can have similar effects. In Tanzania, a radio drama promoted safe sex during the AIDS crisis by creating relatable characters whose behavior sparked group discussions. These conversations spread the message more effectively than top-down campaigns ever could.

So, does change work better from the top down or the bottom up? Well, it depends on collaboration. Grassroots efforts, like Prohibition, can build momentum, but aligning with broader values is essential to sustain change. In Tanzania, the radio drama succeeded because it connected local realities with leadership’s health initiatives. Change rooted in shared identity and values resonates more deeply, making it harder to reverse.

Ultimately, cultural signals and storytelling shift behaviors by redefining what people see as normal. Whether through Prohibition’s public pledges or a soap opera’s aspirational characters, these tools work when they tap into shared values and create a sense of belonging. It’s this alignment that turns cultural movements into lasting societal transformations.
How does culture spread and take root in societies? Let’s take the two main paths addressed in the previous section: grassroots movements and top-down approaches. Both involve different strategies and rely on specific factors to succeed. Let’s explore how these mechanisms work and what they reveal about cultural change.

Grassroots movements often begin with small, everyday actions that grow into broader ideals. Take Gandhi’s movement for Indian independence. Rather than solely resisting colonial rule, it began with visible, symbolic acts like spinning yarn and making salt. These simple actions connected with people’s daily lives, creating a sense of shared purpose. Gradually, they transformed into larger efforts to challenge institutions, from boycotts of British goods to nonviolent protests.

On the other hand, top-down approaches rely on leaders or institutions to enforce change. Consider Sweden’s decision to switch to driving on the right side of the road. The government announced the change, implemented it quickly, and backed it with significant planning and public education. This institutional push forced a cultural shift, not just in traffic habits but in everyday behaviors, like how people walked on sidewalks.

So, what makes these approaches work? For grassroots efforts, success often depends on starting small and relatable. A great example is Ambato, Ecuador’s campaign to promote punctuality. It began by targeting habits, like making buses run on time, before expanding to schools and media to build pride around punctuality. By showing visible results early, the movement gained momentum and slowly reshaped community values.

Top-down efforts, meanwhile, require trust in leadership and alignment with people’s broader aspirations. Poland’s economic reforms in the 1990s are a case in point. Known as “shock therapy,” these drastic measures were painful, but they worked because people trusted their leaders and saw the changes as essential for national independence.

But both strategies come with risks, however. Grassroots movements can falter without clear goals or organization. Occupy Wall Street, for example, drew massive attention but lacked the leadership and focus needed to create lasting change. Similarly, top-down approaches can fail if they move too quickly or ignore public sentiment. Russia’s attempt at economic liberalization after the Soviet Union’s collapse met widespread resistance because people weren’t prepared, and many felt nostalgic for the old system.

Ultimately, whether change comes from the ground up or the top down, success depends on understanding the context and sequencing actions carefully. Aligning habits, ideals, and institutions is the key to making cultural shifts stick.
Why do organizations tell stories? It’s because shared narratives are one of the most powerful ways to bring people together. By creating a shared story, organizations build identity, loyalty, and a sense of belonging across its workforce. And these stories aren’t random; they’re carefully crafted to reflect the organization’s values and history. They might highlight a company’s humble beginnings, celebrate a key anniversary, or focus on the legacy of an iconic leader. The key is authenticity – when a story feels consistent and meaningful, it becomes much easier for people to connect with it.

Traditions are another important part of this process. They’re how organizations build collective memory. Think of Thanksgiving in the US – even though its historical accuracy is debated, it has become a unifying tradition for the nation. Companies do something similar. Harley-Davidson, for instance, emphasizes its heritage by hosting rallies and showcasing vintage designs, reminding its customers of the brand’s long standing identity. Leaders also create or adapt traditions when they need to. Nelson Mandela, for example, framed South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission using local ideas like ubuntu, which emphasizes community and reconciliation. By tying new initiatives to familiar cultural practices, Mandela made them more relatable and impactful.

These stories often work because they tap into universal, almost instinctive human needs. People naturally admire heroes, respect traditions, and seek a sense of connection to a larger group. Organizations that craft narratives reflecting these instincts can inspire loyalty and action. Whether it’s celebrating a historic milestone or invoking the values of a heroic figure, these stories resonate on a deep, emotional level.

Leaders rely on this emotional connection during difficult moments. The NFL, for instance, used its centennial celebrations to highlight football’s rich history and heroic figures, aiming to rebuild its reputation after recent challenges. These kinds of narratives work best when they emphasize selective recall – highlighting parts of history that support current goals – and resonate with familiar symbols or values. When done well, they strengthen identity and inspire people to rally around a shared vision.

In the end, stories are more than just tools for communication – they inspire action. They bring people together, give them a shared purpose, and create momentum. But there’s a risk, too. If a story feels manipulative or inauthentic, it can backfire, creating distrust instead of loyalty.
Have you ever noticed how people seem to split into “us” versus “them” groups, especially in politics or online spaces? That’s toxic tribalism at work. It’s a modern twist on something humans have always done: sticking with our group to feel safe and supported. In its original form, tribalism helped us cooperate and survive. But today, it often divides us instead. Social media plays a big role in this, creating echo chambers where people only hear ideas they already agree with. Algorithms show content that confirms someone’s existing beliefs, which makes their views feel more “right” and others’ more “wrong.” On top of that, where people live – like cities versus rural areas – reinforces these divides.

When tribalism gets toxic, it’s more than just disagreeing. People start living in completely separate realities. For example, someone might firmly believe climate change is a hoax, while someone else sees it as an urgent crisis. These divides create distrust, making it almost impossible to cooperate on important issues. Even everyday choices, like where people shop, reflect this polarization. Think about how Whole Foods is seen as a “Democratic” store and Cracker Barrel as a “Republican” one. This kind of symbolic division turns almost everything into a political statement, deepening the sense of “us versus them.”

There are ways to turn things around though, starting with focusing on shared values. For instance, environmental activists have convinced conservative audiences to care about climate change by framing it in religious terms, like protecting Earth as God’s creation. Similarly, using familiar language – like calling something a “carbon offset” instead of a “tax” – makes ideas more acceptable to different groups.

Another approach is connecting on neutral ground. Talking about nonpolitical topics, such as describing a perfect day, can help people relate to each other as individuals. In sports, for example, Iraqi soccer teams made up of players from different ethnic groups showed that working together could reduce mistrust after just one season.

Leadership also plays a role. Companies such as Coca-Cola pair senior managers with younger employees from underrepresented groups, creating bonds that last. Programs such as Intel’s minority hiring efforts show that inclusivity can be intentional and effective.

Even symbols matter. Catalonia, for example, has reduced cultural tensions by blending traditions at festivals. For example, it introduced alternative dishes for Muslims who avoid pork. Removing divisive symbols, such as Confederate statues in the US, has also shown promise in easing old hostilities.

Toxic tribalism isn’t inevitable. The instincts that divide us can be rechanneled to bring us together. Whether it’s through shared goals, neutral connections, or inclusive leadership, small changes can add up to a bigger sense of belonging for everyone.
In this lesson to Tribal by Michael Morris, you’ve learned that cultural instincts, such as cooperation, rituals, and storytelling, are central to how humans connect, adapt, and build societies. These instincts, which once ensured survival, continue to shape how groups form identities, solve problems, and work together.

Cultural instincts influence both division and unity. While they can create a sense of belonging, they can also lead to polarization when differences are emphasized over common ground. Understanding how these instincts operate provides insights into how to bridge divides and create shared purpose.

Storytelling is also a key tool for driving change. Narratives resonate emotionally, shaping values and behaviors by creating a sense of normalcy and belonging. When aligned with shared values, stories can redefine societal norms, inspire collaboration, and create lasting transformations.

Cultural change can occur from the bottom up through grassroots movements or from the top down through institutional reforms. Both approaches rely on careful alignment of habits, ideals, and trust in leadership. By understanding how cultural instincts operate and finding ways to rechannel them, it becomes possible to turn division into opportunities for unity and collective progress.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Buoyant by Susie deVille The Entrepreneur’s Guide to Becoming Wildly Successful, Creative, and Free

Lessons Learnt on 27th January 2025

The End of Alzheimer's Program by Dale Bredesen The First Protocol to Enhance Cognition and Reverse Decline at Any Age