Cyber Citizens by Heidi Boghosian Saving Democracy with Digital Literacy

What's it about?
Cyber Citizens (2025) explores how our digital lives fundamentally impact democracy. It discusses the importance of becoming smarter digital citizens as surveillance, misinformation, and AI-generated content reshape our information landscape – and reveals practical strategies for staying informed while protecting your privacy.

Every day, you surrender personal data to tech giants and government agencies online. In return, you’re bombarded with targeted ads, click bait, and dangerous misinformation. The truth has become almost impossible to navigate.

But what if there were a better way?

This lesson reveals how digital interconnectedness threatens democracy – and what you can do to save it. On top of practical tools for digital self-defense, you’ll discover why the internet is ripe with political extremism, why surveillance capitalism has gone unchecked for so long, and how new privacy laws are challenging the status quo.

Whether you’re a concerned parent, frustrated voter, or simply someone who wants to reclaim autonomy in a hyper-connected world, you’ll find a blueprint for becoming a digitally empowered citizen.
Many young Americans consider themselves digital natives. They’ve grown up with the internet, so they feel hyperliterate in handling its complexity. But who ever taught them how to read?

It turns out Americans’ digital literacy is heavily lacking. On social media, untrustworthy news sources make up one-fifth of news engagement. Thirty-four percent of Americans avoid going online entirely due to difficulty or disinterest. Of those who do go online, 38 percent are unable to perform more complex digital tasks.

Undeniably, many Americans also have difficulties distinguishing facts from opinions online. This contributes to the recent phenomenon of “truth decay,” which encompasses categories like “fake news.” People disagree on basic facts, trusting personal experience over verified sources.

Now consider this sobering reality: most Americans would fail a basic citizenship test that new immigrants must pass. In one study, only Vermont residents managed to pass on average, while nationwide, a mere 22 percent of students achieved civics proficiency. Over 70 percent of adults can’t name the three branches of government. This isn’t just embarrassing trivia, it’s a democratic emergency.

American citizens today don’t understand how their government works and can’t navigate the digital world safely. This twin crisis threatens the very foundation of democratic society.

The roots of this crisis trace back to the 1960s, when schools largely abandoned civics education in favor of STEM subjects. Today, federal funding reflects these misplaced priorities: out of $54 spent per student, only 5 cents go toward civics education. The result? About one-third of young adults now support having a strong leader who bypasses elections and legislatures entirely.

The situation is so dire that in Rhode Island, several high school students sued the government for failing to teach basic civics, arguing that events like January 6th revealed the dangers of civic ignorance. They won, forcing the state to establish civics task forces and diploma requirements.

These teen pioneers understood that the stakes couldn’t be higher. Without proper civic education combined with digital literacy, citizens become vulnerable to manipulation and disinformation, potentially undermining democratic participation itself.
Let’s face it: the internet can be a mean, scary place. Just a click away from cute animal videos and cooking tips, you’ll find some of the most evil, hateful, and manipulative content that humanity has to offer.

The digital age has brought an unprecedented transformation of how misinformation and propaganda spread. What once required physical meetings and printed materials now happens instantly across global networks, making everyone more vulnerable to manipulation by extreme positions than ever before.

Consider how white nationalist movements have evolved since the 1980s bulletin boards. Spreading across platforms like Telegram and 4chan, the obscure 1978 neo-Nazi novel called The Turner Diaries has now inspired over 200 murders. Even after the January 6th attack on the Capitol, users celebrated by comparing the event to a chapter in the book, showing how viral extremist content reaches massive new audiences.

The recruitment tactics have become disturbingly sophisticated. Some extremists now target young people through gaming platforms like Roblox and Call of Duty, using humor and memes to gradually introduce radical ideologies. Fifteen percent of young gamers now encounter white nationalist themes in their online spaces. The Buffalo shooter who killed Black shoppers in 2022 later posted on Discord that he owed his ideology to the game Blood and Iron.

Meanwhile, scams exploit our digital illiteracy with devastating results to individuals. Take the story of elderly New Yorker Louise who sent over $250,000 from her retirement to scammers who gained her trust over months. Identity theft now affects one in ten Americans annually, largely because people lack basic digital hygiene practices.

Foreign actors have learned to weaponize these vulnerabilities on a large scale. After the 2016 election, Russian operatives bragged how Americans couldn’t distinguish their fabricated political posts from real ones. The fake Russian Black Matters site actually gained more followers than the real Black Lives Matter, succeeding because Americans couldn’t verify sources or distinguish authentic content from manufactured disinformation.

New technologies are only making things worse. AI tools can hallucinate false information, while deepfakes enable sophisticated video manipulation. Shockingly, 96 percent of this technology is currently used to create nonconsensual pornography targeting.

Technologies for creating manipulative content are becoming cheaper, more sophisticated, and easier to use – a perfect storm where anyone can become both victim and unwitting accomplice in spreading digital deception.
Remember Google’s whimsical company motto, “Don’t be evil?” It seems this lighthearted mission statement didn’t prevent them from becoming the world’s largest surveillance operation.

In the last two decades, we’ve witnessed a dramatic transformation in how technology companies operate, evolving from promises of liberation to a new kind of digital feudalism. Today’s tech giants don’t just sell products – they control entire digital territories, exploiting users to generate wealth by surrendering their privacy and autonomy.

Consider Google’s stunning about-face. In 1998, its founders wrote that better search engines needed fewer ads and promised “unbiased access to information.” They even rejected $3 million from Visa to keep their homepage ad-free. Fast forward to today: Google earns $147 billion annually from advertising, making up 80 percent of their total revenue.

As companies like Google started tracking users across websites – using cookies to build detailed behavioral profiles – simple advertising evolved into what we now call surveillance capitalism.

Many of the big tech companies have evolved into uncontested monopolies – and they’d like to keep it that way. Google’s anti-competitive tactics are breathtaking in scope. One secret program offered $360 million to Activision Blizzard and $90 million to Riot Games to prevent them from creating alternative app stores.

Meanwhile, the privacy promises of the big tech companies prove hollow. Apple built its brand on the famous “1984” commercial, positioning itself as a freedom fighter against corporate control. Yet researchers discovered Apple was secretly tracking users even when they opted out. When requested, the company shares data with law enforcement 90 percent of the time. The gap between marketing promises and actual behavior is as wide as their profit margin.

And the consequences extend far beyond individual privacy. The Cambridge Analytica scandal revealed how Facebook harvested 87 million users’ data to create psychological profiles, designing different ads for different personalities to manipulate voting behavior. Voter suppression targeting African Americans became a key strategy, showing how surveillance advertising threatens egalitarian democratic participation.

Under today’s digital feudalism, we’ve traded our role as citizens for that of consumers. The big tech companies exploit our human psychology to keep us chained to their products while using their vast resources to lobby against privacy legislation that might protect us. And who’s to stop them?
There might be sexier revolutionaries than a couple of EU bureaucrats. But few revolutions were as successful as the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation of 2018.

It was thanks to the GDPR that tech CEOs from Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft, and Amazon all suddenly discovered that privacy was a fundamental human right. Their synchronized declarations weren’t coincidental – they were scrambling to maintain public trust as the world’s most powerful privacy law took effect, replacing a 1994 directive that predated social media and cloud computing.

GDPR delivered real consequences. Amazon paid $887 million in fines, Meta faced $1.3 billion in penalties, and Google handed over $166 million for violations. These fines were calculated as percentages of global revenue, making them painful even for tech giants who previously treated privacy violations as minor business expenses.

But the GDPR didn’t just affect Europe. The regulation transformed privacy practices worldwide through what economists call the “Brussels Effect.” When US companies had to implement GDPR-compliant systems for European users, they often made these privacy protections their global standard rather than maintaining separate systems. For instance, cookie consent rules became stricter everywhere, with prechecked boxes and implied consent replaced by requirements for active opt-in to nonessential cookies.

The GDPR also forced institutions to abandon the practice of “collect first, ask questions later” in favor of genuine privacy risk assessment. Consider a public school that wants to use facial recognition for attendance. Under GDPR, they had to now conduct formal Data Protection Impact Assessments, evaluate risks like identity theft, consider less invasive alternatives, obtain explicit parental consent, and implement strict access controls. This represents a fundamental shift in how organizations approach new technology.

American citizens are responding to this privacy awakening. Password manager usage has risen from 20 percent to 32 percent. Privacy-focused chat and social media alternatives like Signal and Mastodon are proof of a growing demand for platforms that prioritize users over data collection.

However, challenges remain. The US still lacks comprehensive federal privacy legislation, relying instead on a fragmented state-by-state approach that creates compliance burdens. As of 2024, 19 states have passed privacy laws – but the patchwork system provides inconsistent protection. Companies also adapt by cleverly wording or designing consent interfaces, and find new ways to collect data while technically complying with regulations.

Despite these limitations, the GDPR proved that meaningful regulation is possible – and that privacy should be a fundamental right.
American democracy is failing the digital test.

Citizens who can’t evaluate sources are falling for foreign propaganda. Voters who don’t understand data privacy are handing their personal information to manipulative campaigns. Young people who never learned to engage constructively online are retreating into echo chambers. The skills that citizens should have – critical thinking, civic participation, informed debate – now require an entirely new digital dimension that’s barely being taught.

That’s why modern civics education needs to integrate digital literacy as a core democratic skill. Citizens who understand data commodification are more likely to protect their privacy, while those who can evaluate information sources resist manipulation. More than just identifying fake news, users need to understand who controls information and how corporate interests shape media narratives.

Estonia demonstrates what’s possible when a nation commits to digital democracy. Their Tiger Leap program created widespread digital literacy that enabled e-governance, online voting, and e-residency programs attracting global entrepreneurs. Meanwhile, Finnish schools teach critical thinking through fairytales, with manipulative characters resembling deceptive politicians. Students learn to think like detectives, questioning sources and examining evidence across all subjects. The result speaks volumes: Finland tops international rankings for resisting disinformation.

In America, a few promising experiments are emerging. Detroit’s Community Technology Project started as a 45-household pilot and grew to serve 500-plus households while training 300 local “digital stewards.” Their model has been replicated in Seattle, New York, and internationally, showing how local organizing can challenge corporate control.

Creative approaches are expanding civic engagement beyond traditional classrooms. The game Darfur Is Dying gained over two million plays and prompted 10,000 players to email senators about the crisis. Fan communities channel passion for Harry Potter and other beloved stories into social justice causes through organizations like Fandom Forward, using familiar narratives to make activism more accessible.

Yet digital literacy education in the US still lacks national standards. To empower America’s digital citizens, children need to know how to navigate digital environments safely, while adults require ongoing education to resist manipulation. A national commitment to this cause could create less polarized online ecosystems where informed citizens can participate effectively in democratic governance.
Just like you don’t need medical training to practice basic hygiene, you don’t need to be a cyber security specialist to protect yourself on the internet. In this final section, let’s consider what you can do right now to secure your freedom and privacy online.

It starts with basic digital hygiene – often overlooked, but powerful enough to block nearly 90 percent of cyberattacks. What exactly does that entail? Only visit websites showing “https” and the lock symbol in your browser. Create passwords using full sentences instead of random characters – they’re easier to remember and harder to crack. Keep your software updated, since each update patches security holes that criminals actively exploit.

When using AI tools, remember they’re sophisticated programs – not friends. They can present completely false information with total confidence, so always fact-check their responses. Also be aware that social media algorithms are designed to keep you scrolling, often by gradually showing more extreme content that triggers strong reactions.

For families navigating this digital landscape together, education doesn’t have to feel like homework. Some parents have discovered the magic of so-called Privacy Audit Parties, where family members review each other’s device settings. The concept of a “digital tattoo” can help children grasp how their online choices today might affect college applications or job interviews years down the road.

The broader community plays a crucial role in this story. Across the US, crypto parties and tech workshops are popping up, creating spaces where neighbors teach neighbors about digital security.

Use practical tools like Global Privacy Control to opt out of data-sharing, private messengers like Signal to secure private conversations, and Password managers to make protection easier. Of course, as threats continue evolving, staying up to date on scam and manipulation tactics is a form of digital literacy that’s as important as recognizing a phishing email.

Ultimately, protecting democracy in the digital age isn’t just about individual security – it’s about collective resilience. By practicing good digital hygiene, supporting privacy-focused companies, and sharing knowledge with our communities, each person becomes part of a broader movement defending digital rights for everyone.
This lesson to Cyber Citizens by Heidi Boghosian argues that digital literacy is essential to preserving democracy.

Americans today face a double crisis: low digital literacy and limited civic knowledge. That combination leaves people wide open to online manipulation and extremism. The tech giants haven’t helped. What once felt like tools of liberation have morphed into engines of surveillance capitalism – profiting from user data while crushing competition. But it doesn’t have to be this way. Regulations like the GDPR show that real privacy protections are possible, and they’ve already sparked global momentum.

The path forward involves bringing digital literacy and civic education together. Citizens should know not only how to stay safe online, but also how democracy works – and how the two connect. By practicing basic digital hygiene, choosing privacy-first tools, and sharing knowledge in your community, you can protect yourself while strengthening democracy. In the end, digital empowerment isn’t optional anymore; it’s a cornerstone of preserving freedom in a connected world.

Comments